Expectations of the Reader
When you pick up a book, we often know the plot from the outset? A new planet discovered, the main character and his crew are seen as invaders. War ensues. A pirate on the high seas kidnaps the virgin princess. Bodice ripping ensues. Dark night, glum private eye, beautiful woman walks in. Danger and intrigue ensue. And of course, the first person narrator lives to to the tale because, well, we’re reading it.
Does it occur to us that we read the same plots (according to one of the books on my shelf, there are only seven) over and over again? Or is it more important that they entertain? That the writing astounds? Do we care if it’s the same trite story and stock characters as long as it’s a really good trite story and engaging stock characters?
I walk a wide berth around romance whenever I write. I figure it comes down to two things: my own abject failure at love (until this last year), and my own abhorrence for the expected. Angry boy (or girl) meets lost boy (or girl), and you know they will end up together at the end of the story. There’s just a bit too much flattering physical description combined with a little bit of chemistry woven into the dialogue. The reader always knows.
Of course, I’m writing a story now that has, you guessed it, romance. It’s a subplot, not a major theme, but I’ve included the hot, brooding man and the confused, strong woman who’s just starting to realize he’s actually a pretty good guy. It’s so predictable. But again I wonder: is that a bad thing? Do we like that comforting familiarity? There’s plenty of action and blood…so does the foreshadowing of kindling affection ground the reader amid shifting plotlines?
Or am I overthinking all of this? As long as it’s well-written, solidly formed, who cares?